colin-horn-fR9U2S31Exs-unsplash
landscape_logo.png

Russia-Ukraine Conflict: Three Scenarios & Potential Outcomes

Rising tensions between Russia, Ukraine and NATO[i] have the world on edge, and many investors appear to be concerned. A major geopolitical event can send shockwaves through financial markets. However, predicting the behavior of global leaders can be difficult for even the most seasoned foreign policy experts. Here, we look at three scenarios and how those potential outcomes could impact financial markets.

A frozen conflict

Russia, Ukraine and NATO could stay in a frozen conflict, with no party making a move that would significantly escalate the situation. We think this scenario would maintain the status quo, with no additional impact to financial markets or changes in government or central bank policy.

ukraine-infographic-frozen-1200-v1

A partial invasion

In our view, a partial invasion would involve Russia making a land grab in Ukraine and/or initiating an aggressive cyberattack against the country or its allies. In this scenario, we think the US will likely apply some sanctions to Russia. The potential European response is less clear, since many European countries have economic interests in Russia and desire for constructive relations with the country.

We believe markets would have a strong risk-off reaction and then normalize quickly once it’s clear a full invasion is not underway. We would expect a short-lived rally in US Treasurys and the US dollar. In our view, the euro might take a modest hit on risk sentiment, but the currency’s fundamentals should support it longer term. Energy prices would likely spike, with a further rise if energy is included in sanctions. In this scenario, we believe the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank would stay on course, cautiously removing financial accommodation.

ukraine-infographic-partial-1200-v1

A full invasion

If Russia launches a full invasion of Ukraine, we expect more severe sanctions from the US and NATO. In the US, we think Congress would likely move away from the Build Back Better budget in favor of a bipartisan agreement that would raise spending on military and cybersecurity, including a possible tax hike.

We believe markets would have a strong risk-off reaction, with a flight to perceived “safe harbor” assets like US Treasurys and the US dollar. The euro would likely take a temporary hit. In our view, a full invasion would trigger a severe spike in energy prices. We also see a possible impact on aluminum, titanium and uranium prices if Russia uses these commodities for leverage against the West.

In this scenario, we believe the Fed could temporarily delay its initial rate hike. The ECB might step up bond purchases if there is an impact on credit spreads, but any action would be the result of market behavior rather than fundamental deterioration in our view.

ukraine-infographic-full-1200-v1

Russia retains significant leverage against the West

Whatever the outcome, we think it’s important to remember that Russia currently has significant leverage against the West and plays a critical role in the global supply chain beyond oil and gas. The Russian state owns a significant stake in VSMPO-AVISMA, a Russian company that represents more than 30% of the global production of titanium. This company produces approximately 65% of Airbus’s titanium consumption, 35% of Boeing’s and the entirety of Brazilian company Embraer’s.[ii]

Russia’s leverage is not limited to commodities produced within its own borders. Moscow retains enormous influence in other post-Soviet states, including Belarus and Kazakhstan. Belarus is not only a major producer of potash and other commodities, but also home to BelAz, a Soviet-era manufacturer of the largest heavy trucks in the world, used by mines globally. Kazakhstan is a central player in numerous commodity markets, boasting the largest reserves of zinc, tungsten and barite in the world. Kazakhstan also accounts for nearly a quarter of global uranium production, the second-largest reserves in the world.

We believe markets may be underappreciating Russia’s role in these global supply chains. We will be watching this area closely as the situation evolves. For a deeper dive into this topic, read Senior Sovereign Analyst Hassan Malik’s paper, “Consider the Less Obvious Dependencies on Russia.

Read the full "Consider the Less Obvious Dependencies on Russia" paper


WRITTEN BY:

Darcie Sunnerberg, Associate Director, Macro Strategies

Brian Horrigan, Chief Economist

Saurabh Lele, Senior Commodities Analyst

Jon Levy, Senior Sovereign Analyst

Hassan Malik, Senior Sovereign Analyst

Ramsey Andrawis, Macro Strategies Research Analyst

 

[i] North Atlantic Treaty Organization
[ii] Kommersant, 15 November 2021.

MALR028585

Examples above are provided for illustrative purposes only and should not be considered recommendations for action by investors. They may not be representative of current or future investments and they have not been selected based on performance. Loomis Sayles makes no representation that they have had a positive or negative return during the holding period.

Commodity, interest and derivative trading involves substantial risk of loss. This is not an offer of, or a solicitation of an offer for, any investment strategy or product. Any investment that has the possibility for profits also has the possibility of losses.

This blog post is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. Any opinions or forecasts contained herein reflect the subjective judgments and assumptions of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect the views of Loomis, Sayles & Company, L.P. This information is subject to change at any time without notice. Information obtained from outside sources is believed to be correct, but Loomis Sayles cannot guarantee its accuracy. This material cannot be copied, reproduced or redistributed without authorization.

SHARE THIS STORY | |

Search

 

About the Authors

Loomis Sayles analysts are career professionals who offer deep knowledge and experience in a diversity of global asset classes and market sectors. These dedicated experts provide the insight essential to supporting our portfolio management teams across a wide range of investment strategies.

Subscribe to Emails